Friday, May 16, 2014

A Road Map for Population Genomics


In Monday's discussion of Andrew et al. (2013) Road Map for Molecular Ecology we criticized this vision of the future. In particular the sections on phylogeography, hybridization and speciation, don't grapple with the essential problem of how genome data are changing our questions and analyses.

Here are some recent papers that do just that.

  Ellegren (2012) "Genome sequencing and population genomics in non-model organisms" reviews methods for inference of historical demography (PSMC). This is a genome wide analogue of skyline plots, based on varying time to coalescence of different genome segments. It was developed for a single diploid genome (you need some heterozygosity to estimate coalescence time) and has now been extended to multiple individuals. It should be better resolved than one-to-few-gene skyline plots, especially in detecting the signal of multiple expansion-contractions but not necessarily for recent events (which depend on sample size).
Sousa & Hey (2013)  "Understanding the origin of species with genome-scale data: modelling gene flow" go straight to the heart of the matter. Much of the potential power of population genomics comes from recombination. The coalescent genealogical sampling methods that we currently use (BEAST, IMa...) are computationally intensive and can't handle recombination. Recent population genomic studies use summary statistics like Fst and D (single-SNP 4-taxon gene trees). These throw out most information in the data and can't distinguish among processes that may have caused observed patterns. Current methods are simply unable to simultaneously consider implications of many gene-genealogies with varying degrees of linkage but there are some promising approaches that involve computational shortcuts (ABC, PAC) and Hidden Markov Model (HMM) methods that allow changing genealogies along the genome.

Both of these reviews have something to say about detecting selection and the genes underlying phenotypic differences in wild populations - including GWAS, which was not mentioned in Andrews et al. (2013).

Apart from the emerging methods reviewed above I think our road map needs to consider genome-wide inference of admixture. This year there have been some great new resources and approaches to studying individual origins and population histories using admixture. One of these is the Genetic Atlas of Human Admixture History (Hellenthal et al. 2014), with this wonderful web playground. Just a few weeks ago Elhaik et al. (2014..aka The Genographic Consortium) published the "Geographic Population Structure" algorithm (GPS...haha) which uses admixture analysis of Ancenstral Informative Markers (AIMs) to infer the biogeographic origins of populations. Using 100 000 SNPs they were able to assign human individuals to geographic regions with astounding accuracy, to within 50km and often to the right village for some European populations (Sardinia, which is old and structured). This is far better than what is achieved from previous methods such as PCA.

On the other end of the population structure spectrum, we need to know about the new Bayesian assignment methods for species delimitation (BPP), which may be particularly applicable to bar-coding studies. As a parting shot I might add that DNA based trophic ecology (i.e.  CSI - POO) is at best a scenic byway off the freeway of ecological metagenomics; with the as yet unfulfilled promise of detecting rare species, measuring abundance and analysing whole species communities from non-invasive environmental samples. These curious absences in Andrew et al. (2013) are partly because the review aims at concepts not methods. Given that our (potential) ability to generate data is way ahead of theory we need more specific consideration of analyses. 

The Harrison et al. (2014) review of evolutionary potential, which we didn't discuss, is an interesting essay on how we might use experimental analyses of fitness in model organisms to derive measures of adaptive and non-adaptive variation in the wild (giving evolutionary significance to ESUs). Unfortunately the only two organisms cited in their consideration of wild populations are Arabidopsis and Drosophila - I guess we are not quite there yet.

PSMC - Pairwise Sequential Markovian Models
HMM - Hidden Markov Models
Admixture
AIMs - ancestry informative markers
GPS - population structure
BPP - species assignment
Ecological Metagenomics
GWAS on non-model species

That's a long list of emerging techniques to leave off your road map of the future.

Tuesday, March 25, 2014

Lineage identification - Comparison of methods



Dear Meepers,

Find below the tree that we can use to delimit the lineages using the different methods available.

The phylogenetic tree represents different lineages of the mouse Micaelamys namaquensis. You can find the full article following the link http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2148/10/307.


Friday, February 28, 2014

Date Name
17-Feb-14 Connor
24-Feb-14 Kerry
03-Mar-14 Anton
10-Mar-14 Tessa
17-Mar-14 Carel
24-Mar-14 Michael
31-Mar-14 Samantha
07-Apr-14 Ilkser
14-Apr-14 Public holiday
21-Apr-14 Public holiday
28-Apr-14 Paulette
05-May-14 Arrie
12-May-14 Catherine
19-May-14 Masethabela
26-May-14 Sarita
02-Jun-14 Stephen
09-Jun-14 Carel
16-Jun-14 Public holiday
23-Jun-14 Connor
30-Jun-14 Anton
07-Jul-14 Amanda
14-Jul-14 Tessa
21-Jul-14 Masethabela
28-Jul-14 Ilkser

Friday, July 19, 2013

Date Name
22-Jul-2013 Thierry
29-Jul-2013 Michael
5-Aug-2013 Sarita
12-Aug-2013 Carel
19-Aug-2013 Kerry
26-Aug-2013 Angelika
2-Sep-2013 Stephen
9-Sep-2013 Arrie
16-Sep-2013 Samantha
23-Sep-2013 Ilkser
30-Sep-2013 Bianca
7-Oct-2013 Paulette
14-Oct-2013 Catherine
21-Oct-2013 Thierry
28-Oct-2013 Michael
4-Nov-2013 Sarita
11-Nov-2013 Carel
18-Nov-2013 Kerry
25-Nov-2013 Angelika
2-Dec-2013 Stephen
9-Dec-2013 Arrie

Friday, May 3, 2013

Discovery of a new phylum: from barcoding to taxonomy

One of the new way to discover cryptic diversity is to sequence environmental clone libraries. In 2007, researcher discovered a new and very deep lineage of picoeurcaryote from plankton samples using 18S. After years of survey, they could finally isolate this unicellular organism and describe it. The cell is 3.0 x 2.2 micrometers, it is biflagellate, it has a single mitochondrion and has a unique stereotypic motility. Based on these features, they decided to establish a new phylum: Picozoa. It is a nice example on how genetics helps in biodiversity survey and taxonomy. The paper was published the 26 March in Plos One (see reference below).

Figure 2. A Picomonas cell. 2A. Differential interference contrast of a chemically fixed cell. Inset shows phase contrast image of a live cell from tissue culture flask photographed with an inverted microscope (Scale bar 5 µm). 2B. Fluorescence and phase contrast overlay, nucleus (blue), mitochondrion (red). 2C. SEM image. 2D. A longitudinal section through a cell in the plane of the flagella, viewed from the cell’s left. 2E. A 3 D serial section reconstruction of the cell depicted in 2D. AF/PF (anterior−/posterior flagellum); AP/PP (anterior/posterior part of the cell); G (Golgi body); M (mitochondrion); MB (‘microbody’); N (nucleus); tr1,tr2 (distal [tr2] and proximal [tr1] flagellar transitional regions); P (posterior digestive body); Cl (cleft separating the anterior from the posterior part of the cell); vc (vacuolar cisterna). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0059565.g002

Source: Seenivasan R, Sausen N, Medlin LK, Melkonian M (2013) Picomonas judraskeda Gen. Et Sp. Nov.: The First Identified Member of the Picozoa Phylum Nov., a Widespread Group of Picoeukaryotes, Formerly Known as ‘Picobiliphytes’. PLoS ONE 8(3): e59565. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0059565

Tuesday, April 23, 2013

From the jungle to The Dell

Wallace Anniversary - Commemorating a great Evolutionary Biologist


2013 is the 100th year since the death of Alfred Russell Wallace (8th Jan 1823 - 7th Nov 1913), in the words of David Quammen "the best field naturalist of the nineteenth century." See Quammen's retrospective review of Wallace's seminal book, "The Malay Archipelago".

Wallace tends to get short shrift in evolutionary compendiums, especially those from the mid-20th century. This is probably because he held to some unconventional ideas that, with more information, were largely rejected as unnecessary, wrong or irrational. This is unfortunate because, as Darwin himself recognised, Wallace was an impressively original independent thinker. His 1855 Sarawak paper, which he also discussed with Darwin, raised the concept of regional allopatric speciation leading to sister species in adjacent areas. In his Ternate paper, he independently arrived at the concept of evolution by natural selection, leading to the joint presentation with Darwin to the Linnaean Society. A later paper on the biogeography of Malesia first described his eponymic disjunction between Bali and Lombok in Indonesia, although the term "Wallace's Line" came later (I'm not quite sure who coined it, probably Huxley in 1868. I want to note too that Wallace was not the first, nor the only great biogeographer working in Malesia around that time, both Müller and the Sclater brothers also drew lines in the same area, viz Simpson "Too many lines").

Among diverse interests Wallace was a socialist, who campaigned for nationalisation of land and protectionism in the first era of global trade. He was also interested in mysticism - communing with spirits through séances - in fact he did not believe that evolution applied to the human mind or soul (greatly to the dismay of Darwin and peers such as Huxley, Hooker and Lyell). But, he was also a very modern thinker in other senses, being an environmentalist concerned with extinction far ahead of his time. Even more so, in his last decade he wrote two books on exobiology and the unlikelihood of life on Mars (perhaps responding to HG Wells's 1989 War of the Worlds).

Wallace and Darwin maintained good relations and a lively correspondence throughout Darwin's life - much of it in strident, though amicable disagreement.

Should anyone care to purchase a lovely portion of evolutionary history's history, The Dell, a house built by Wallace in Grays on the lower Thames, England, is up for sale (although perhaps you may first need a lottery ticket).


Saturday, January 26, 2013

Journal club schedule - 1st semester 2013

Date Name
28-Jan-2013 Kerry
4-Feb-2013 Angelika
11-Feb-2013 Stephen
18-Feb-2013 Michael
25-Feb-2013 Arrie
4-Mar-2013 Thierry
11-Mar-2013 Samantha
18-Mar-2013 Sarita
25-Mar-2013 Carel
1-Apr-2013 Public holiday - Family Day
8-Apr-2013 Paulette
15-Apr-2013 Bianca
22-Apr-2013 Ilkser
29-Apr-2013 Catherine
6-May-2013 Kerry
13-May-2013 Angelika
20-May-2013 Stephen
27-May-2013 Michael
3-Jun-2013 Arrie
10-Jun-2013 Thierry
17-Jun-2013 Public holiday
24-Jun-2013 Samantha
1-Jul-2013 Sarita
8-Jul-2013 Carel